Pursuant to the Industrial Property Code No. 6769 (IPC), it is legally permissible to establish a pledge over a registered trademark and to place an attachment upon it through enforcement proceedings. Since a trademark constitutes an asset possessing independent economic value distinct from the commercial enterprise, it may be subject to forced execution and collateralized in the same manner as a debtor’s other assets. These transactions become effective upon registration in the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office register.

How is an attachment of a trademark executed?

An attachment of a trademark is executed pursuant to an attachment order issued by the competent enforcement office within the scope of an enforcement proceeding file upon the creditor’s request. The enforcement directorate notifies the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TÜRKPATENT) via formal judicial writ to record the attachment of the registered trademark in the name of the debtor into the register. The transaction becomes effective against third parties upon the entry of the attachment annotation into the institutional register.

The enforcement office examines the trademark registry records registered under the debtor’s name and directly transmits a notice of attachment to the registration records. In order for the attachment to acquire binding effect, the notice must be received by the TÜRKPATENT registry and duly registered. An attachment not recorded in the register cannot be asserted against bona fide third parties who subsequently acquire rights.

Following the entry of the attachment annotation, the debtor is barred from transferring the trademark, waiving the trademark right, or engaging in legal dispositions that diminish the trademark’s value. The enforcement directorate further serves an attachment notice upon the debtor, communicating that the trademark has been attached and that the debtor’s power of disposition has been restricted.

How is a pledge established over a trademark?

A pledge over a trademark is established through the execution of a written pledge agreement between the trademark proprietor and the creditor and the registration of this agreement in the register. Under the Industrial Property Code No. 6769, a written pledge agreement is a validity requirement for pledging a trademark independently of the enterprise. Asserting the pledge against third parties is contingent upon the registration requirement.

A trademark pledge may be established via two distinct procedures. The first method is the execution of an independent trademark pledge agreement pursuant to Article 148 of the IPC. The second method is the establishment of a pledge via the Register of Pledged Movables under the Law on Pledges over Movable Assets in Commercial Transactions No. 6750.

The following procedural steps are observed during the pledge process:

  1. A written pledge agreement containing the registration number of the trademark and the collateral amount is drafted.
  2. The signatures of the parties are authenticated by a notary public to ensure legal certainty.
  3. An application for the registration of the pledge is filed before TÜRKPATENT, and the requisite official fee is paid according to the current tariff.

How is an attached or pledged trademark liquidated?

In the event of default by the debtor, the attached or pledged trademark is liquidated by sale at public auction through the enforcement office. Governed by the provisions of the Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004 (EBL), this sale is conducted in accordance with the procedure for the sale of movable property. After deducting the enforcement and proceeding expenses from the sale proceeds, the remaining balance is disbursed to the creditor.

During the sale process, the enforcement office designates an expert committee to conduct an appraisal (valuation) of the trademark. The experts determine the reserve price (minimum estimated value) by assessing the trademark’s reputation, registered classes, market share, and commercial turnover. The parties reserve the right to challenge this valuation before the enforcement court.

Upon finalization of the appraisal, an auction is opened on the electronic sales portal. Once the auction price is paid, the enforcement office issues a notification to TÜRKPATENT for the registration of the trademark in the name of the new owner.

How does the attachment or pledge of a trademark affect license rights?

The attachment or pledge of a trademark does not automatically terminate license agreements duly recorded in the register prior to the attachment or pledge. Previously registered exclusive or non-exclusive license rights retain their validity against the creditor who subsequently attaches the trademark and against the new owner who acquires it through forced execution.

For licensees to be protected, the license must be registered in the TÜRKPATENT register. Unregistered license rights cannot be asserted against bona fide parties who attach or acquire the trademark through a pledge.

License relationships concerning pledged and attached trademarks are governed by the following rules:

  • In the absence of a restrictive clause in the pledge agreement, the trademark proprietor may continue granting licenses to third parties.
  • Licensing transactions deliberately diminishing the economic value of the trademark may be revoked upon objection by the pledgee creditor.
  • An action for revocation of disposition may be instituted with respect to licenses granted with the intent to prejudice creditors following an enforcement attachment.

Which court has jurisdiction over disputes regarding trademark attachments and pledges?

The court with subject-matter jurisdiction over disputes concerning trademark attachments and pledges is either the enforcement court or the civil court of intellectual and industrial property rights, depending on the nature of the dispute. Objections regarding the form of enforcement proceedings, appraisal valuations, or the annulment of the tender are heard before the enforcement court; whereas actions concerning the substance of the trademark right, the invalidity of the pledge agreement, or cancellation from the register are instituted before the civil court of intellectual and industrial property rights.

Accurate determination of the competent court in intellectual property disputes prevents procedural dismissal of the action. In jurisdictions where no specialized civil court of intellectual and industrial property rights is established, the civil courts of general jurisdiction adjudicate in that capacity. For example, within the judicial district of Antalya, the Antalya Civil Court of Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights has jurisdiction over actions for trademark invalidation, cancellation of a pledge, or rectification of the register.

For complaints arising from enforcement proceedings and actions challenging the appraisal valuation, the enforcement court situated within the territorial jurisdiction of the relevant enforcement office holds subject-matter jurisdiction. For example, for proceeding files before the Antalya Enforcement Directorates, the forum of objection is designated as the Antalya Enforcement Court.

What are the common errors encountered in trademark attachments and pledges?

The most common error in trademark attachments and pledges is the omission to register the transactions in the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office register. Even if a pledge agreement is executed before a notary public or an attachment order is issued by the enforcement office, rights acquired by third parties in good faith remain protected so long as the annotation is not entered into the register, exposing the creditor to the risk of losing collateral protection.

The primary errors resulting in forfeiture of rights by the parties include:

  • Failure to verify registration status: Subjecting trademarks that are merely at the application stage or that have lapsed to legal proceedings confers no legal protection.
  • Missing the renewal deadline: Failure to pay the renewal fee for trademarks whose ten-year term of protection has expired leads to abandonment and lapse of the trademark; the creditor must personally monitor this timeframe.
  • Defective appraisal: If the intangible value of the trademark is not determined by qualified experts, the liquidation process stalls, or the asset is disposed of below fair market value.
  • Failure to monitor likelihood of confusion: Failing to file oppositions against conflicting subsequent applications, thereby condoning the dilution of the trademark’s distinctiveness and commercial value, weakens the collateral.

Hypothetical scenario

The following case is illustrative. An enterprise establishes a pledge over its registered trademark as collateral for a commercial credit facility secured from a bank. The parties execute a notarized pledge agreement and record the transaction in the TÜRKPATENT register. Upon default in repayment on the maturity date, enforcement proceedings are initiated via foreclosure of the pledge. Experts appointed by the enforcement office determine the reserve price by examining the trademark’s balance sheet data and market goodwill. At an auction conducted electronically, the trademark is adjudicated to the highest third-party bidder. Enforcement costs and the credit debt are satisfied from the realized proceeds, and the process concludes with the registration of the trademark in the name of the new owner.

Frequently asked questions

Can an unregistered trademark be subject to a pledge or attachment?

No, it cannot; only trademarks registered in the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office register may be subject to a pledge or judicial attachment. Because unregistered signs lack the capacity to support rights in rem or to be subject to judicial attachment, no official attachment annotation or pledge entry can be established over such signs.

How does the expiration of the trademark protection term affect an attachment or pledge right?

The trademark right lapses; if the trademark is not renewed upon the expiration of the 10-year term of protection, it is cancelled from the register. Because the pledge and attachment become null and void upon termination of the underlying right, the creditor is authorized to maintain trademark protection by paying the official renewal fee within the statutory period.

May the debtor continue using the attached trademark as a trade name and on business signage?

Yes, such use may continue; even if the trademark has been attached, the debtor may utilize the trademark in its enterprise until the forced sale is concluded and ownership is transferred to the new purchaser. However, the debtor is obligated to refrain from bad-faith acts that impair the trademark’s reputation, recognition, or economic value.

Is it possible to transfer a pledged trademark to a third party?

Yes, it is possible; however, because the pledge right is recorded in the register, title to the trademark transfers encumbered with the existing pledge obligation. Since the new purchaser acquires the trademark with constructive notice of the pledge annotation, they must bear the risk of the trademark being liquidated through forced execution in the event the underlying debt remains unsatisfied.

References

  • Industrial Property Code No. 6769
  • Enforcement and Bankruptcy Law No. 2004
  • Law on Pledges over Movable Assets in Commercial Transactions No. 6750

This text is for general informational purposes; legal outcomes may vary depending on the specific circumstances of each concrete case.