An action for design invalidation is a legal remedy providing the deregistration of a design registered before the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office despite failing to satisfy statutory requirements. The cancellation decision rendered as a result of this action filed pursuant to the Industrial Property Code No. 6769 (IPC) retroactively nullifies the registration entirely.

What is an action for design invalidation?

An action for design invalidation is an industrial property dispute entailing a claim to invalidate, by court decree, registered designs that lack or subsequently lose the protection requirements stipulated in the legislation. Resulting in the cancellation of the registration certificate, this legal remedy aims to eliminate an unjustified shield of protection and restore fair competition.

When an invalidity judgment is rendered, the monopoly right conferred by the registration ceases with retroactive effect from the application filing date. Because novelty examination during design registration is conducted in a limited scope within our legal system, instances of registering designs previously disclosed to the public are frequently encountered. Right holders or third parties whose commercial activities are adversely affected by the illegitimate registration must apply to judicial authorities to remove these obstacles to protection.

If the design right is held invalid, the registrant cannot assert claims of infringement against third parties based on the registered design, claim damages, or demand the recall of products from the market. An invalidation action functions as an effective defense and simultaneously as an offensive instrument against the illegitimate registrant.

What are the grounds for the invalidation of a design registration?

The grounds for the invalidation of a design registration comprise legal deficiencies exhaustively enumerated in the law, principally that the design lacks the requirements of novelty and individual character. The lack of genuine entitlement on the part of the applicant or contrariety to public order also leads to the court-ordered cancellation of the registration.

Pursuant to Article 79 of the IPC, design invalidity may be claimed on the following primary grounds:

  • Lack of novelty: The circumstance where the design was made available to the public anywhere in the world prior to the application filing date. The prior exhibition of a form in brochures, on the internet, at trade fairs, or through sales channels destroys novelty.
  • Lack of individual character: The situation where the overall impression produced by the design on the informed user (an attentive consumer knowledgeable about products in the relevant sector) does not sufficiently differ from designs already disclosed to the public. Minor differences in detail do not suffice to confer individual character.
  • Technical necessity: Design protection cannot be granted where the appearance features of the product are dictated solely by a technical function.
  • Lack of genuine entitlement: The fact that the design registration applicant is not the actual creator of the design and has not acquired the right constitutes a ground for cancellation.
  • Contrariety to public policy and morality: An invalidity judgment is rendered if the design contains elements detrimental to public order.

Who has standing to file an action for design invalidation?

Standing to file an action for design invalidation belongs to natural or legal persons possessing a legitimate interest in the cancellation of the registration, as well as to right holders claiming to be the actual creators of the design. Relevant professional chambers, public prosecutors, and commercial enterprises subjected to the threat of illegitimate registration also possess the right to file this action.

Although the concept of interested party is interpreted broadly, any person whose commercial activities are hindered by the unjustified design registration, who has been served with a cease-and-desist letter, or who faces the risk of an infringement action may initiate proceedings. Where the invalidity ground relies on genuine entitlement, the right of action belongs exclusively to the actual creator of that design or their legal heirs; in such case, unrelated third parties lack standing to sue (the legal capacity to bring the action).

Actions grounded in contrariety to public policy or morality may also be brought before the court ex officio by public authorities and public prosecutors without requiring a legal interest condition. The defendant is the person appearing on the design register as the right holder or their assignees.

Which court has subject-matter and territorial jurisdiction over design invalidation actions?

The court of subject-matter jurisdiction in design invalidation actions is, as a rule, the Civil Court for Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights. In courthouses where this specialized court is not established, jurisdiction is exercised by the local Civil Court of First Instance.

Regarding territorial jurisdiction, the baseline rule designates the court of the defendant’s domicile. If the defendant is not domiciled in Turkey, the competent forum is the court where the registered representative’s place of business is located, or, in the absence of a registered representative, the Ankara courts where the headquarters of the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office are situated.

For instance, if the defendant’s domicile falls within the borders of Antalya, the dispute is heard by the Antalya Civil Court for Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights. In smaller districts lacking a dedicated intellectual property court, the action is brought before the generally competent Civil Court of First Instance acting in the capacity of an intellectual and industrial property rights court.

Within what time limit must an action for design invalidation be filed?

As a rule, an action for design invalidation may be brought at any time throughout the 5-year protection period of the registration and, where renewed, during the active registration term. Even if the design right has expired, invalidity may still be claimed after the protection term has ended, provided that continuing legal interest is proven.

In invalidation actions based on genuine entitlement to the design, general statutes of limitations and preclusive periods become critical. In cases of bad-faith registration, no preclusive period applies; bad faith on the part of the registrant may be asserted at any stage to request cancellation. Where bad faith is absent, the right to sue may be restricted by the expiration of specific statutory periods from the registration date pursuant to the applicable legislation.

To institute proceedings after the expiration of the design right, the plaintiff must retain a retrospective legal interest. For example, an enterprise previously sued for compensation due to design infringement preserves the right to file an invalidation action even after the design term has elapsed to eliminate that illegitimate liability threat.

How does the litigation procedure proceed in an action for design invalidation?

The litigation procedure in a design invalidation action is governed by the written procedure, which commences with the submission of the statement of claim to the court and payment of the required court fees. Following completion of the exchange of pleadings stage between the parties, the preliminary examination hearing is held and the points of dispute are framed.

Expert examination forms the core backbone of the proceedings. Whether the designs are similar, the existence of prior publicly disclosed products, and the degree of individual character are reviewed through technical experts and design specialists. The principal stages of the process proceed in the following order:

  1. Submission of the statement of claim and response: The plaintiff submits all evidence, including prior-dated catalogues, invoices, and internet records; the defendant asserts the validity of the registration.
  2. Preliminary examination and collection of evidence: The court defines the dispute, assesses possibilities of settlement, and summons the registration files from official authorities.
  3. Expert panel examination: A panel comprising an industry expert and an intellectual property jurist compares the designs and prepares an expert report.
  4. Investigation and judgment: Objections to the expert report are examined, supplementary reports are ordered if necessary, and the court decides on the partial or complete invalidation of the design.

Once the judgment becomes final, the court sends a copy ex officio to the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office, and the design is struck from the record through deregistration from the register.

How is the burden of proof handled in design invalidation actions?

The burden of proof in design invalidation actions rests on the plaintiff claiming that the design fails to meet the protection requirements. The plaintiff must prove through definitive and concrete evidence that the contested design was disclosed to the public prior to the application filing date.

Various evidentiary means are utilized to prove prior disclosure of the design:

  • Notarized documents and commercial ledger records bearing definitive dates,
  • Sales invoices and waybills predating the design application date,
  • Periodicals, printed product catalogues, and trade fair participation certificates,
  • Digital archive searches, time-stamped webpage printouts, and registered domain name historical records.

The most common procedural defect is the failure to prove the date of the submitted evidence. Internet screenshots without verifiable dates or brochures lacking print dates are not accepted alone by courts as evidence refuting novelty. Therefore, evidence must prove beyond doubt that it originates from a date prior to the application date.

Hypothetical case scenario

The following case is fictional. A furniture manufacturing enterprise learns that a coffee table model it introduced to the market has been registered as a design by a third party under the third party’s own name. The registrant sends a cease-and-desist letter to the enterprise demanding that product sales cease. In this case, the manufacturer may file an action before the Civil Court for Intellectual and Industrial Property Rights accompanied by invoices, catalogues, and social media posts demonstrating that the coffee table was offered for sale prior to the registration application. If the court establishes through an expert examination that the design was not novel on the application date, it decrees the invalidation of the registration and the monopoly right is expunged from the register.

Frequently asked questions

Is mediation mandatory in an action for design invalidation?

No, mediation is not a mandatory condition precedent in actions where only the invalidation of the design and its deregistration from the register are sought. However, if a retrospective claim for damages or monetary compensation is asserted alongside the invalidation action, recourse to mediation is mandatory regarding those monetary claims.

Can invalidation be requested for only a part of a registered design?

Yes, where certain elements within the design registration fail to satisfy the legal requirements, the court may be requested to render a partial invalidation decision. For a partial invalidation judgment to be granted, the remaining parts of the design must independently continue to maintain the conditions of registrability.

Can an interlocutory injunction be requested while a design invalidation action is pending?

Yes, the plaintiff may request an interlocutory injunction to prevent the assignment of rights arising from the registration to third parties or to stay enforcement proceedings in order to avert irreparable harm. If the court deems it necessary, it may temporarily suspend the exercise of exclusive rights in the design against security.

What items constitute the litigation costs of a design invalidation action?

Litigation costs consist of the initial application and advance court fees, notification and postal expenses, and expert witness fees. Because the amounts of these items are updated annually under Ministry of Justice fee tariffs, the official tariff in force at the time of filing must be reviewed.

Sources

  • Industrial Property Code No. 6769
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100

This article is provided for general informational purposes; outcomes may vary depending on the specific circumstances of the actual case.