A limited liability company should be incorporated for local operations requiring low capital and few partners, whereas a joint-stock company should be established for business models requiring high capital and aiming for growth and investment. Regulated under Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (TCC), these two types of capital companies embody fundamental differences regarding partner liabilities, minimum capital amounts, and share transfer procedures. Entrepreneurs must decide in accordance with their corporate objectives and risk preferences.
What is the difference in partner liability between a joint-stock company and a limited liability company?
Shareholders of a joint-stock company are liable only to the company up to the capital share they subscribed; they bear no personal liability toward creditors. Partners of a limited liability company likewise cannot, as a rule, be held directly liable toward company creditors, and their liability is limited to their subscribed share of the basic capital (the total capital amount subscribed in the articles of association).
The most distinct difference in liability regimes is observed upon the company’s bankruptcy or insolvency. In a joint-stock company, if a shareholder has paid their subscribed capital contribution to the company in full, their personal assets cannot be pursued for company debts. In a limited liability company, provided that a partner performs the capital obligation undertaken in the articles of association, they attain, as a rule, similar protection regarding private law debts.
In contrast, the capacities of partner and manager yield distinct legal consequences in both company forms. Limited liability company managers or joint-stock company board members authorized to represent and bind the company are held personally liable pursuant to Article 553 of the TCC for damages they inflict upon the company, partners, and company creditors in the event of fault in the performance of their duties.
How is partner liability for public debts regulated?
Partners of a limited liability company are directly liable with their personal assets, in proportion to their capital shares, for public debts such as taxes, social security premiums, and default interest that cannot be collected in whole or in part from the company. Conversely, shareholders of a joint-stock company bear no personal liability whatsoever for unpaid company public debts, provided they do not hold the capacity of legal representative.
This aggravated liability regime in limited liability companies arises from Article 35 of the Law on Collection Procedure of Public Receivables No. 6183 (LCPPR). For a public receivable that cannot be collected from the company’s assets, a payment order may be issued directly against a partner of a limited liability company. Even if the partner transfers their share, they remain jointly and severally liable with the transferee for public debts belonging to the pre-transfer period.
In joint-stock companies, pursuant to duplicate Article 35 of the LCPPR, liability for public debts belongs exclusively to the board members managing and representing the company. A joint-stock company shareholder who does not serve on the board of directors cannot under any circumstances be pursued with their personal assets for the company’s tax or premium debts. This fundamental rule represents a leading factor in favoring the joint-stock company model in high-risk sectors.
What procedural differences exist between limited liability and joint-stock companies regarding share transfers?
In joint-stock companies, share transfers are, as a rule, completed freely by delivery or endorsement of the share certificate without requiring notarial certification or registration. In limited liability companies, however, share transfers are subject to strict formal requirements that take effect through a written transfer agreement executed before a notary public, general assembly approval, and registration with the trade registry.
Pursuant to Article 595 of the TCC, the share transfer agreement in limited liability companies must be signed by the parties and the signatures certified by a notary public. For the transfer to be valid, the general assembly must approve the transaction; unless otherwise provided in the articles of association, the general assembly may reject the transfer request without stating a reason. Following general assembly approval, the transfer must be registered and announced in the trade registry; otherwise, the transfer cannot be asserted against third parties.
In joint-stock companies, where share certificates have been issued pursuant to Article 489 et seq. of the TCC, registered share certificates are transferred by endorsement and transfer of possession, while bearer share certificates are transferred solely through transfer of possession. The validity of the transfer is not contingent upon general assembly approval or registration; the transfer is entered into the company share ledger. Furthermore, if joint-stock company share certificates are held for at least 2 years from their acquisition date prior to disposal, the realized gain may benefit from specific tax exemptions.
What legal requirements govern corporate bodies and management structures?
While the mandatory bodies of joint-stock companies consist of the general assembly and the board of directors, limited liability companies maintain a general assembly and a manager or board of managers. In both corporate forms, the general assembly functions as the supreme decision-making body wherein the partners express their corporate will.
Key differences in management structures are set forth below:
- In limited liability companies, at least one partner is legally required to hold the title of manager possessing management and representation authority; management authority cannot be transferred entirely to a non-partner third party.
- In joint-stock companies, board members are not required to be shareholders; the board of directors may consist entirely of non-shareholder professionals.
- The board of directors of a joint-stock company may consist of a single individual or multiple members; legal entities may also be elected as board members.
Disparities also exist regarding the terms of office of management bodies. Limited liability company managers may be elected for an indefinite term unless stipulated otherwise in the articles of association or by general assembly resolution. Pursuant to Article 362 of the TCC, joint-stock company board members are elected to serve for a maximum term of 3 years; they may be re-elected unless the articles of association provide otherwise.
How does the trade registry registration process operate during incorporation?
Company incorporation commences with the electronic preparation of the company’s articles of association via the Central Trade Registry System (MERSİS) and achieves legal entity status upon registration with the trade registry. The trade registry directorate located at the company’s headquarters possesses jurisdiction over registration procedures.
The sequential steps required during incorporation include:
- Obtaining a potential tax identification number via the MERSİS system and preparing the company’s articles of association,
- Signing of the articles of association by the founders at the trade registry directorate alongside identification documents and necessary authorization letters,
- Depositing the Competition Authority share into the relevant bank account,
- Preparing the registration petition and chamber registration declaration and submitting them to the registry directorate,
- Publication of the registered company in the Turkish Trade Registry Gazette.
For instance, entrepreneurs establishing a company in the province of Antalya conduct their registration applications before the Antalya Trade Registry Directorate. Following registration, statutory books are notarially certified, and the tax office inspection process is concluded prior to commencing commercial operations.
Which company type offers advantages in public offerings and fundraising?
Joint-stock companies retain an absolute advantage over limited liability companies regarding their capacity to conduct initial public offerings, issue corporate bonds, and attract capital from domestic or foreign investment funds. Limited liability companies are legally prohibited from executing public offerings or issuing bonds to raise debt financing.
Venture capital funds and institutional investors prefer investing exclusively in joint-stock companies due to flexible capital increase mechanisms and reduced procedural burdens in share transfers. Structuring shares as preferred shares (conferring voting or dividend advantages over ordinary shares) facilitates investor participation in management within joint-stock companies.
Even if growth-oriented enterprises commence operations as limited liability companies, they frequently undergo corporate conversion (changing the legal form of the company) upon reaching fundraising or public listing phases. Pursuant to conversion provisions set forth under Article 180 et seq. of the TCC, a limited liability company may be converted into a joint-stock company without interruption to its assets and legal rights. In the event of partner disputes, lawsuits may be initiated, for example, before the Antalya Commercial Court of First Instance.
Hypothetical scenario
The following scenario is fictitious. Two founding partners commence commercial operations by establishing a limited liability company with equal shares. During operations, market conditions deteriorate, rendered the business unable to satisfy its public debts. The tax office serves a payment order upon each partner in proportion to their shares for the public receivable uncollectible from the company’s legal estate. One partner seeks to initiate litigation, asserting that they are not personally liable for company debts. However, personal liability attaches to their assets due to public debts accrued under limited liability company partnership status; payment or restructuring of this debt may be demanded. Had joint-stock company status been maintained without serving on the management board, such enforcement could have been precluded.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legally permissible to incorporate a joint-stock or limited liability company with a single person?
Yes, pursuant to the provisions of Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102, both joint-stock and limited liability companies may be incorporated by a single natural person or legal entity founder. In single-member companies, all shares are held by one person, and general assembly powers are exercised by this sole partner.
Under what conditions does the obligation to retain legal counsel apply to joint-stock companies?
Pursuant to Article 35/3 of Attorneyship Law No. 1136, joint-stock companies whose basic capital exceeds the statutory threshold set forth by law are required to retain an attorney under contract. An administrative monetary fine is imposed for each non-compliant month; no such statutory requirement exists for limited liability companies.
How is a resolution regarding the expulsion of a partner from a limited liability company adopted?
Where just causes exist, limited liability company partners may petition the court for the partner’s expulsion, or the expulsion procedure may be executed via a general assembly resolution on grounds specified in the articles of association. An expulsion compensation corresponding to the fair market value of the share must be paid to the expelled partner.
Are incorporation expenses identical for both company types?
No, the mandatory pre-registration bank deposit requirement for a specific portion of the capital and statutory book certification expenses create distinct cost items for joint-stock company incorporations. Incorporation fees, chamber registration dues, and capital thresholds vary annually based on officially published tariffs.
References
- Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102
- Law on Collection Procedure of Public Receivables No. 6183
- Attorneyship Law No. 1136
This article is intended for general informational purposes; outcomes may vary depending on the specific facts of an individual case.



