An unfair competition lawsuit is initiated by parties whose economic interests are damaged or endangered due to commercial acts contrary to the principle of good faith, through a statement of claim submitted to the competent Commercial Court of First Instance, preceded by a mandatory mediation process. Initiated under the Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102 (TCC), this action is brought with claims for the determination of the act, its cessation, the elimination of its consequences, and compensation for pecuniary or non-pecuniary damages incurred.

What is unfair competition and which commercial practices does it encompass?

Unfair competition refers to any economic competition and commercial practice that affects relations between competitors or between suppliers and customers, and is deceptive or otherwise contrary to the principle of good faith. Under Article 54 of the TCC, the primary objective is to ensure that all market participants operate in a fair and undistorted competitive environment, thereby safeguarding both honest merchants and consumers.

Article 55 of the Law lists non-exhaustively the most common instances of unfair competition encountered in practice. These acts are not limited in number, and any commercial practice contrary to market ethics and the principle of good faith may be assessed as unfair competition:

  • Disparaging the goods, work products, activities, or commercial reputation of others through false or misleading statements.
  • Attempting to gain an unfair advantage by providing misleading information regarding one’s own commercial standing, products, business capacity, or pricing.
  • Creating similarities likely to cause confusion (likelihood of confusion) with another’s registered or unregistered distinctive name, trade name, trademark, or emblem.
  • Inducing another’s employees or commercial agents to breach their confidentiality obligations, or unlawfully obtaining proprietary trade secrets.
  • Deceiving customers and diverting them to one’s own business through misleading advertisements and untruthful commitments.

What are the conditions for initiating an unfair competition lawsuit?

The conditions for filing an unfair competition action are: the occurrence of a concrete competitive act in the market contrary to the principle of good faith; the plaintiff’s economic interests being damaged or directly endangered as a result of this act; and the action being filed within the statutory limitation period before the competent and venue-holding court. The plaintiff bears the burden of proving the concrete acts constituting unfair competition and their adverse impact on its own commercial activities.

Direct competition for customers between the parties or merchant status for both parties is not required to initiate proceedings. Pursuant to Article 56 of the TCC, customers, consumer organizations, or professional associations may also institute an unfair competition lawsuit when the economic interests of their members are damaged or face the threat of harm.

Unlike claims for determination and cessation, where damages are claimed, it is mandatory to establish fault on the part of the defendant and an adequate causal link between the unlawful act and the damage sustained. If the conditions of fault or damage are not satisfied, claims for compensation are dismissed; however, judgments for declaratory relief and prevention may still be rendered.

Which court has subject-matter jurisdiction and venue in unfair competition lawsuits?

The court with subject-matter jurisdiction in unfair competition lawsuits is, as a rule, the Commercial Court of First Instance; even where the parties are not merchants, the dispute constitutes an absolute commercial cause of action if governed by the TCC. Territorial jurisdiction (venue), pursuant to the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, lies with the court of the defendant’s domicile, or the court where the act of unfair competition was committed or where the damage occurred.

In judicial jurisdictions without an independent commercial court, these cases are heard by the Civil Court of First Instance sitting in its capacity as a commercial court. For instance, in a dispute where the commercial enterprise or the damage arising from the act is located within the borders of Antalya, the lawsuit must be filed before the Antalya Commercial Courts of First Instance.

In commercial claims involving monetary receivables or damages, application to the mediation bureau is mandatory pursuant to the Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes No. 6325 prior to filing the statement of claim with the court. Claims for damages initiated directly without attaching the final mediation report to the statement of claim are dismissed on procedural grounds.

What relief may be claimed from the court in an unfair competition lawsuit?

In an unfair competition lawsuit, the plaintiff may petition the court for a declaration that the act constitutes unfair competition, the cessation of the unfair competition, the rectification of the unlawful state of affairs, and, if fault exists, compensation for damages sustained. These remedies granted under Article 56 of the TCC may be asserted successively or cumulatively, depending on the scope of the violation and necessity.

The legal claims that a plaintiff may request from the court include:

  1. Declaratory claim: A binding determination by the court that the commercial act committed or ongoing constitutes unfair competition by law.
  2. Claim for cessation (injunctive relief): The immediate termination and prohibition of the ongoing act of unfair competition or an act posing an imminent risk of recurrence.
  3. Elimination of the material state of affairs (restitution/remedial claim): Elimination of the consequences produced by the unfair competitive act, correction of misleading statements, and destruction or recall from the market of infringing materials or instruments used in their manufacture.
  4. Pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages: Monetary redress for actual losses, loss of profits, and injury to commercial reputation suffered as a result of proven fault.
  5. Publication of the judgment: Announcement of the summary of the judgment to the public through publication once the decision becomes final, at the expense of the losing party.

What is the statute of limitations for filing an unfair competition lawsuit?

The right of action for unfair competition is time-barred upon the expiration of 1 year from the date the plaintiff acquires knowledge of the right, and in any event after 3 years from the date the act of unfair competition was committed. In actions filed after the expiration of these periods prescribed under Article 60 of the TCC, if the defendant raises a statute of limitations defense, the case is dismissed without an examination on the merits.

If the infringing act also constitutes a criminal offense subject to a longer statute of limitations under penal codes, the extended criminal limitation period applies to the civil action as well. In cases where the unfair competition continues uninterruptedly, the limitation period does not begin to run until the conduct has completely ceased.

Filing fees and the advance on costs payable when instituting proceedings are determined according to the nature of the dispute and the amount of damages claimed. As fixed and proportional fee tariffs are republished at the beginning of each calendar year, the current judicial fees schedule on the date of filing must be reviewed.

What are the common mistakes made in unfair competition lawsuits?

Common errors in unfair competition disputes include: failing to secure evidence through due procedural channels in a timely manner, failing to exhaust the mandatory mediation procedure, and missing the 1-year subjective limitation period. Furthermore, the inability to prove pecuniary loss through concrete commercial books and records and the incorrect choice of subject-matter jurisdiction lead to dismissal of meritorious claims on procedural grounds or prolonged delays lasting years.

Frequently observed missteps in practice are:

  • Delaying the preliminary securing of evidence: As misleading statements on websites or imagery of counterfeit goods can be rapidly removed, failure to secure evidence pre-action via a notary public or the Civil Court of Peace weakens the evidentiary position.
  • Omitting mediation as a cause of action prerequisite: Direct application to the court for lawsuits containing a claim for compensation results in procedural dismissal of the action.
  • Failing to request an interlocutory injunction: Overlooking that ongoing violations during proceedings may erode commercial goodwill and failing to seek a preliminary injunction at the outset results in irreparable harm.
  • Confusing subject-matter jurisdiction: Where the dispute contains an industrial property aspect, the jurisdiction of specialized courts must be observed over courts of general jurisdiction; for instance, where no specialized intellectual and industrial property rights court exists, such as generally across Antalya, the jurisdictional determination must be made accurately.

Hypothetical example

The following scenario is fictional. An enterprise operating within a market sector uses the online product catalogs, promotional copy, and registered design elements of a local competitor across its own channels without authorization; additionally, it dispatches discounted solicitations to a client portfolio acquired from an employee who recently departed that competitor. In this scenario, the aggrieved enterprise may first secure existing digital evidence via a notary public or the Civil Court of Peace. Subsequently, through an unfair competition lawsuit filed before the Commercial Court of First Instance, it may seek a determination of the infringement, cessation of the use of infringing materials, return of client lists, and pecuniary damages for lost turnover.

Frequently asked questions

Can an unfair competition action be filed for an unregistered trade name or business identifier?

Yes, an unfair competition lawsuit may also be filed for unregistered names and distinctive signs. Registration is not mandatory to benefit from Turkish Commercial Code protection; actual use in the market, acquired goodwill, and the causation of likelihood of confusion contrary to good faith are sufficient.

Is sending a cease-and-desist letter mandatory prior to filing an unfair competition lawsuit?

No, serving a cease-and-desist letter via a notary public on the counterparty prior to filing an action is not a statutory prerequisite of the claim. However, in practice, serving a formal notice significantly aids the evidentiary process by seeking immediate cessation of the breach, documenting the counterparty’s fault and bad faith, and mitigating further potential damage.

Can an interlocutory injunction be obtained in unfair competition lawsuits?

Yes, an interlocutory injunction may be requested from the court in cases of urgency or where a risk of irreparable harm exists. Pending final resolution of the case, the court may order the cessation of distribution of infringing goods, seizure of brochures, or blocking of access to misleading websites.

Do consumers have the right to file a lawsuit for unfair competition?

Yes, consumers and customers may also initiate proceedings when their interests are impaired by misleading or deceptive commercial practices. Consumers may seek a declaration of the unfairness of the act and the elimination of the unlawful condition; if they have sustained direct injury from the tortious act, they may also file a claim for compensation.

How is the quantum of damages determined in an unfair competition lawsuit?

The quantum of damages is determined by assessing the actual loss sustained and the lost profits suffered by the plaintiff. A court-appointed expert panel calculates the amount by examining the probable revenue the plaintiff would have generated had the defendant not engaged in the unfair competitive conduct, alongside the unjust enrichment acquired by the defendant from the infringement.

References

  • Turkish Commercial Code No. 6102
  • Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100
  • Law on Mediation in Civil Disputes No. 6325

This article is for general informational purposes; legal outcomes may vary depending on the specific facts of each case.