The lawsuit for collusive disposition by the decedent, commonly known as evading assets from inheritance, is initiated by submitting a petition and paying court fees before the competent Civil Court of First Instance to annul collusive transfers executed by the decedent to conceal real property from other heirs. Relying on Article 19 of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TCO) No. 6098, the plaintiff heir establishes with documentary evidence that the true intent of the decedent was a donation rather than a sale, and claims title registration in proportion to their inheritance share.

What is an action based on decedent’s collusion and which transactions does it cover?

An action based on decedent’s collusion is an action for title cancellation and registration aimed at invalidating simulated (collusive) transactions, wherein the decedent, seeking to evade assets from heirs, disguises a real property intended for donation as a sale or a contract of maintenance for life at the land registry. This legal remedy secures the inheritance shares protected by law for the heirs.

As a rule, the decedent has the testamentary freedom to dispose of their assets at will during their lifetime. However, when the decedent conceals their true intent and executes an apparent contract of sale to deprive certain heirs of their inheritance rights, the transaction enjoys no legal protection. In such transactions, the apparent contract of sale is invalid because it does not reflect the true intent of the parties, while the concealed contract of donation is void for failure to comply with the statutory formal requirements prescribed by law.

The lawsuit in question applies solely to registered immovable property. In cases where the decedent transfers funds from bank accounts, delivers cash by hand, or transfers movable property, an action based on decedent’s collusion cannot be filed; where legal conditions are met, an action for reduction becomes applicable. The most common scenario in practice involves the gratuitous transfer of familial real properties to a specific heir while disguising the conveyance as an official sale in the land registry.

Who has standing to file an action for evading assets from inheritance?

Legal heirs, testamentary heirs, and adopted children whose inheritance shares have suffered prejudice due to the collusive transaction executed by the decedent possess standing to sue following the death of the decedent. The law does not mandate that the plaintiff be an heir holding a reserved portion (the statutory minimum inheritance share reserved for specific heirs that the decedent cannot dispose of).

No distinction of share is made among heirs holding active legal standing. Descendants, the surviving spouse, or parents regarded as reserved-portion heirs may file this action, and siblings lacking a reserved portion may likewise initiate litigation alleging collusion. All heirs who have not renounced the decedent’s inheritance or have not been disinherited retain the right to seek cancellation and registration in proportion to their respective inheritance shares.

Circumstances where standing to sue is lacking are expressly limited by statute:

  • Persons who waived their rights by executing a valid contract of renunciation of inheritance with the decedent cannot file an action.
  • Heirs who unconditionally disclaim the inheritance forfeit their legal standing to sue.
  • No heir can initiate this action while the decedent is alive; the accrual of the right is contingent upon the death of the decedent.

What are the elements of a lawsuit based on decedent’s collusion?

To initiate a lawsuit based on decedent’s collusion, the concurrent existence of an apparent contract of sale, a concealed contract of donation reflecting the parties’ true intentions, an intent to defraud the heirs, and a collusion agreement between these two transactions is required. If any of these constitutive elements cannot be proven in the dispute, the action is dismissed on the merits by the court.

The first element, the apparent contract, is the transfer transaction executed by the parties before the official officer at the land registry office. The parties record in the land register that a transfer was made for valuable consideration; in reality, however, no consideration has been paid by the transferee to the transferor.

The second element is the concealed intent to donate held by the parties. The decedent intends to convey the real property gratuitously, and the counterparty accepts this donation. Pursuant to the provisions of the Turkish Civil Code (TCC) No. 4721 and the TCO, real property donations must be executed before an official officer with the intent to donate; thus, the concealed donation transaction is deemed absolutely null and void due to lack of formal compliance.

The third and most decisive element is the decedent’s purpose to deprive the other heirs of their inheritance rights. If the decedent transferred the real property at a fair market value to discharge an actual debt, cover medical and living expenses, or sustain commercial activities, no fraudulent intent arises and the allegation of collusion will not be sustained.

Which court has jurisdiction over an action based on decedent’s collusion?

An action based on decedent’s collusion is brought before the Civil Court of First Instance where the real property in dispute is located. Pursuant to Article 12 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) No. 6100, because the rule of exclusive territorial jurisdiction governs disputes concerning rights in rem (ownership rights) in immovable property, lawsuits initiated before courts outside the judicial district where the property is situated are dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

The value of the real property or the legal status of the parties plays no role in determining subject-matter jurisdiction. The judicial forum vested with exclusive subject-matter jurisdiction over claims for deed cancellation and registration based on allegations of evading assets from inheritance is the Civil Court of First Instance. Even though the court of the decedent’s last domicile holds general jurisdiction over inheritance matters, the situs of the real property prevails pursuant to the rule of exclusive jurisdiction in actions based on real property ownership.

For instance, if the conveyed real property lies within the territorial boundaries of Antalya, the lawsuit must be filed before the Antalya Civil Courts of First Instance. In cases where multiple real properties were conveyed simultaneously and are located across different territorial jurisdictions, bringing a single action for all properties before the court of the situs of any one of the properties is permissible.

What are the procedural stages of initiating an action based on decedent’s collusion?

The process of initiating an action based on decedent’s collusion consists of gathering evidence after the decedent’s death, drafting the petition, applying to the competent court, issuing the preliminary proceedings report, the examination stage, and rendering the final judgment. Supporting allegations with concrete means of proof at every step of the process is decisive for the outcome of the litigation.

The litigation process proceeds through the following stages:

  1. Determination of evidence: Bank account statements of the decedent at the date of the transaction, obvious discrepancies between the transfer value in the land register and the fair market value, witness testimony, and familial relations between the decedent and the heirs are determined prior to filing the action.
  2. Petition and request for preliminary injunction: In the petition submitted to the competent court, an entry of preliminary injunction (a provisional legal protection safeguarding the right where delay poses prejudice) on the land registry record is requested to prevent the transfer of the subject real property to third parties.
  3. Examination and judicial inspection: The court investigates the financial capacity of the decedent at the date of transfer, whether a genuine necessity to sell property existed, and the purchasing capacity of the transferee through official institutions. A judicial inspection is conducted on-site with an expert witness to determine the actual value as of the transfer date.
  4. Judgment and enforcement: Upon proving the claims, the court orders the cancellation of the title deed registration of the real property in proportion to the plaintiff heirs’ inheritance shares and its registration in their names; the finalized judgment is enforced at the land registry office.

What are the common mistakes made in lawsuits for evading assets from inheritance?

The most common mistake made in lawsuits for evading assets from inheritance is attempting to initiate litigation while the decedent is still alive, or conflating an action for reduction with an action based on decedent’s collusion. Such procedural and substantive legal errors result in the direct procedural dismissal of the case without consideration of the merits due to the absence of a cause of action.

Another prevalent procedural error is omitting the request for a preliminary injunction against the title deed record in the petition. If the defendant conveys the real property to a bona fide third party while litigation is pending, regaining ownership of the real property becomes impossible by virtue of the protection under Article 1023 of the TCC, converting the subject matter of the lawsuit solely into a claim for monetary compensation.

Deficiencies in evidentiary submissions also precipitate forfeiture of rights. Relying solely on abstract witness statements, failing to introduce bank records of the decedent and the transferee as of the transaction date into the case file, and ignoring local customs and traditions at the date of conveyance may cause the dismissal of the lawsuit. Furthermore, failure to deposit the advance ad valorem fee based on the value of the action or non-compliance with peremptory time limits set by the court leads to procedural dismissal.

Hypothetical example

The following case is fictional. The decedent, aiming to conceal a valuable residence from other heirs, conveys it to a single heir by executing an official transaction of sale at the land registry. No record of payment collection appears in the decedent’s bank statements, and the transferee lacks regular income or savings capable of purchasing the property at that date. Upon the death of the decedent, the other legal heirs, discovering the circumstances, petition the competent Civil Court of First Instance, asserting that the apparent sale was simulated. The court places a preliminary injunction on the title deed record, and an examination of expert reports and bank records establishes that the conveyance constituted a donation; accordingly, cancellation of the title registration in proportion to their inheritance shares and registration in the names of the heirs may be claimed.

Frequently asked questions

Is there any statute of limitations or forfeiture period in an action based on decedent’s collusion?

There is no statute of limitations or forfeiture period; since a collusive transaction is deemed void ab initio, the action may be filed at any time following the death of the decedent. However, to prevent the loss of evidence and forestall the conveyance of the real property to third parties, initiating the action without delay is recommended.

Can a lawsuit for evading assets from inheritance be filed for movable property or bank deposits?

No, an action based on decedent’s collusion can as a rule only be filed for transfers of registered immovable property. In cases where the decedent transfers funds from bank accounts or donates movable assets such as vehicles, an action based on decedent’s collusion cannot be filed; rather, where statutory requirements are satisfied, an action for reduction protecting the reserved portion or an action for recovery to the estate must be initiated.

Can the title deed be recovered if the subject real property has been sold to a third party?

Yes, if the third party acquiring the real property knew or ought to have known of the collusive circumstance, the title deed may be cancelled. However, if the third party acted in good faith and remained unaware of the simulated conveyance, the title registration cannot be cancelled; in that case, the plaintiff heirs may claim monetary compensation corresponding to their shares from the defendant who alienated the real property.

How are court costs and legal fees calculated in an action based on decedent’s collusion?

The action is subject to an ad valorem fee; fees and court costs are calculated on the current market value of the real property in dispute as determined by judicial inspection. Upon filing the lawsuit, the plaintiff heir deposits an advance ad valorem fee calculated over their proportional share; the current fee schedule must be consulted regarding litigation costs.

References

  • Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098
  • Turkish Civil Code No. 4721
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100

This article is for general informational purposes only; outcomes may vary depending on the specific facts of a concrete case.